Illegal Immigrants

One of the diarists I frequently read wrote something shocking this weekend.  She stated that she didn’t mind educating the children of illegal immigrants, that it benefited everyone in the long run.

On the surface that sounds all warm and fuzzy.  But when you actually THINK about what it takes and who bears the burden, that kind of blanket statement is ludicrous in my mind.  I will grant you right up front that it is not the fault of the children—they did not ask to be here. 

Let me explain my position based on a scenario here in suburban Philadelphia.  We have a once-thriving community that has fallen on hard times when manufacturing left.  There is little tax base left to subsidize the school district.  Consquently the school tax is higher than the neighboring school districts and the children receive don’t receive comparable ameneties as in the neighboring school districts.

This community has become a haven for illegal immigrants.  The numbers are staggaring.  The schools are over-run with the illegal children, many of whom cannot even speak English.  That means they receive extra attention and draw attention from the regular students.  That means IEP’s and ESL programs which fall under Special Education.  The state only provides so much money for Special Education and now there isn’t enough to go around and children that truly have special needs (down’s syndrome, autism, dyslexia, etc…) do not and cannot receive the education they should because we are teaching the Mexicans to speak English.

The school district operates at a defecit trying to accomdate the influx of illegal aliens they are forced to educate.  How do you handle the defecit?  You raise the taxes.  What happens when you raise the taxes?  The senior citizens living on fixed incomes can no longer afford the property taxes (aka school taxes) and are forced to move.  I ask how THAT benefits everyone in the long run?

I will acknowledge that the Mexican community is very hard working.  HOWEVER, they are getting paid cash under the table.  That means they are not paying their share of taxes.  There are multiple families living under one roof, so once again they are not paying their share of taxes.  Yet we provide their illegal children with a FREE education.  And we provide them with FREE health care when they have another child.

The diarist who doesn’t mind paying for the education of the illegals stated that she doesn’t have children so she is paying to educate other children, so there really isn’t much difference.  But there is.  Someone paid to educate me and I am paying it forward.  I am paying it forward to the children of tax paying parents.  And in the process I am paying back those that paid to educating me by paying my share of taxes so that my "benefactors" can stay in their homes.

Supporting the education of illegal aliens does a disservice to the LEGAL children in schools.  It does a disservice to me by increasing my taxes.  And it does a HUGE disservice to the senior community that can not afford to pay the continually increasing property taxes.

Illegal immigrants hurt everyone.  And GIVING them Social Security benefits is absolutely ludicrous.

Contrary to what you might think, I do not hate or even dislike Mexicans or any other nationality.  I hate illegal immigration.  Come here LEGALLY, pay your fair share, learn to speak the language and be an active member of the community and I will welcome you with open arms.

Log in to write a note
September 19, 2007

Unfortunately, our economy depends on illegal immigration. If you’re willing to pay more for, say, produce, then by all means deport those who are accepting jobs no American would take. After studying in Los Angeles and learning more about illegal immigration and speaking with numerous maquilladora workers in Tijiana, I’m afraid our very economic system allows it to continue. The immigrants (who are not only Mexican, but who are from other countries in Central America) are also fleeing their home countries because of the terrible economic systems they are under. I know, I know; many who share your opinion would say, “Well, that’s not our problem,” but we take advantage of their plight by hiring them and paying them little to nothing so that we wouldn’t have to pay a United States citizen more. We abuse the circumstances. And those who are more conservative, who truly care about business, are hesitant to give that up. Just offering another perspective and some experience. I did follow your guidelines by thinking first, so I hope that we can at least agree to respectfully disagree… Take care. ~*

September 20, 2007

I couldn’t have said it better. I soooo totally agree with you on this. It especially galls me when I see employers posting ads for “spanish-speaking” this or that …. if you are going to live in OUR country, the least you can do is learn our language. And I have a big problem with the illegal immigration period. Enough said.

November 12, 2007

ryn: I’ve posted the cranberry recipe, as requested.

MRS
November 16, 2007

ryn: You do that!!! Hey with you I could probably send you to one of MY bars to do the shot!!! Thanks!

November 21, 2007

ryn: Many thanks for the link! I will check it out.

November 22, 2007

RYN: my last diary colors included the colors of my bridesmaids dresses….wine or burgundy. Bright colors are hard on the eyes.

December 28, 2007

RYN: Yeah I tried Resolve. Like two different kinds of it so I’ll try that OxyClean next.

ed.
January 11, 2008

ryn: i definitely don’t mind waiting. he’s not one to say something unless he really means it. i just kind of hoped we were both at that point by now. it makes me a little sad considering how much we’ve been through and how long it’s been, but i really don’t mind waiting until he can say it and mean it. i really just hope we’ll get there.

January 11, 2008

RYN: We dont want to declaw!! That is like an absoulute last resort But i dont see us going that way I like the idea of the softpaws

January 25, 2008

Ryn: I’ve told everyone already- a LOT of people have done the vax here though, so I doubt anyone will want to have a CP party a long with us lol