Stolen survey with moral questions

I Stole this from a favorite… just for something to post.

Answer honestly what you would do in certain situations. Don’t try to be the ultimate girl/boy scout.

1. You’re in the grocery store and notice a mother yelling at her 3 yr old son for being whiny. But she won’t stop and keeps calling the boy names. The boy starts to cry and now the mother starts to spank him and yelling at him to stop. What would you do?

There is a big, big difference between discipline and public humiliation. I have spanked Ethan… but I save that only for the most horrible infractions like pushing his little brother or almost setting the house on fire. The worst of the worst basically. And I feel that children deserve to be disciplined at home in private, not publically, so if I saw something like that… I would and did do something.

One day I was at Walmart, and I witnessed a woman verbally tell off her kid and then slap the 3 year old girl so hard on the arm, it left quite a bruise just for whinning too much. I walked over to the mother and calmly asked her to stop immediately and control herself. She looked at me with disgust and then asked me, who the hell do you think you are? I paused for a moment and then calmly replied, “I work for social services.”

Those five words send the mother of all chills up her spine and her face turned very, very pale. I could tell she was scared to death, and we stood there for almost a full minute saying nothing. I had my cell phone in my hand (cause I was calling leah to confirm what she wanted from Walmart) but gave her my best ‘don’t do that again’ look and then walked away. I think the lady learned that day to be very careful, you never who might be watching when you’re out in public…

2. You’re in the park enjoying a nice sunny day when you notice a couple having an argument. Your normal curiosity takes a hold of you and you start to really pay attention to what they are arguing about. Out of the blue he smacks her in the face while holding her wrist extremely tight. What do you do?

I’d use my cell and call the cops. This could be domestic violence if they’re married, or the start of a date rape if they’re not… so I’d let the boys in the blue deal with which ever it happens to be.

3. You are walking down a busy sidewalk and the person in front of you drops a $100 bill. What do you do?

I would give it back to the owner. If I found it and didn’t know who it belonged to, then I would keep it but if I knew who the owner is… then I would return it. That’s my pesonal policy.

4. You are having lunch at a nice restaurant and notice one of your friend’s spouse having an intimate lunch without their better half. It seems innocent at first as they having a great time, laughing and talking. But then you notice that they hold hands from time to time and then a few kisses ensue. What do you do?

A friend of mine came across this exact situation, and dealt with it rather admirably. When his friend’s spouse left to go to the bathroom, he bolted as well and intercepted her at the door and confronted her. He gave her the mother of all ultimadums: You tell him tonight, or I tell him tomorrow. One way or another he’s finding out. I hope that if I ever come across that situation, I would have to courage to be that brave for my friend.

5. You head to Walmart to pick up a few things. As you attempt to park your front bumper smacks into the driver side door of the car in the next stall. What do you do?

I would get out and inspect the damage. If there was any dents or anything, I would leave insuarance info on the windshield. If there was nothing, I wouldn’t leave anything… it’s that simple.

6. You get your monthly bank statement and notice that the last deposit you thought was only $50 the bank mistakenly put $500 in your account. What do you do?

I would call the bank to confirm if it is an error. For all I know someone else could have made a $450 deposit and not tell me about it. If it is an error then I would let the bank know so that they can fix it.

7. You’re sitting on the bus or train and notice an elderly man walking real slow and limping and there are no empty seats. What do you do?

I’ve come across this many times, and I give up my seat every time. I’m young and the bus drivers punch the brakes too much in this city to the point where I’m afraid they could break some elderly person’s hips. So I do it for them and the extra good karma…

8. You are late for a very important date (business or pleasure) and you just witnessed a car accident take place in front of you. You’ve seen exactly what happened but there is plenty of room to continue driving. What do you do?

If I was that close to witness an accident I would stop to make sure everyone was all right and dail 911 to make sure help was coming.

Also… in this country, you have to stay. Leaving the scene of an accident is a federal offence… even for witnesses. If someone saw me leave and took down my lisence plate number and reported me, I could be subject to criminal charges.

Even so, I would stay not only to make sure everyone is ok but because I witnessed the accident just to make sure the story was reported and the police had the right details about what happened. If the person who I am supposed to meet can’t understand my reason for being late under those circumstances, than that is a person I don’t want to associate with.

Peter

Log in to write a note
May 4, 2008

Re. #1: Clever! 🙂

May 4, 2008

And by the way, I don’t buy the ‘mind your own business’ argument that I’m sure some people will rebuke you for regarding #1 and #2. If you do something like that in a public place, it ceases to have the slightest pretense of being a private matter.

May 4, 2008

I once ignored an abusive parent in a store. It was the day after my father died and I was spent. I was ashamed of myself and vowed I would never do that again. Not only would I say something BUT I would call security. I do think, however, that the parent will take it out on the kid later. If a parent is abusive in public they are likely worse at home.

May 4, 2008

I would never involve myself in marital infedelity by telling a friend unless I was willing to give up the friendship. I once let a friend and her two children live with us for a time bcause her husband was abusing them. She went back to him and our friendship died. I don’t regret it but I still believe that involving yourself in another person’s marital problems is a mistake.

May 4, 2008

As for #1, I love that my husband is a social worker and a mandated reporter. We haven’t had to use it, surprisingly enough. I have called the cops on a neighbor having a domestic dispute. I heard them struggling and he said “I’ll break your f’in arm!” The cops did come and as far as I know left the couple at home since they had “smoothed things over” or whatever. I was disgusted that she didnot let the cops take him away, but those are her issues, not mine.

Good for you on #1.

May 4, 2008

I like your answers

May 4, 2008

interesting answers. some, like the old man one, are no brainers. or at least , they better be!

CW
May 4, 2008

I completly disagree with #4. Yes, the other spouse may / will find out eventually, but it is not your place to be the moral police. You have no idea what the status of their marriage is. Maybe they know their SO is out, and doesn’t really care, but the humiliation of being found out in public could be horrifying. People always, always, ALWAYS know when their other is straying, even if theydon’t acknowledge it. Forcing the issue can have devastating effects. Sorry, a note is clearly not the best place to go into this very complex issue. But in something so extraordinarilly sensitive, it is always best to MYOB, and then be there as a supportive friend, if needed, when the other shoe does fall. =;p

May 24, 2008

i think all of these questions are answered differently if you live in steel town 1. I get away before the store clerk punches the shit out of the out of hand mom 2…. i get out of the way before the cops get here 3… i call to the person who dropped it quickly and put my foot on it so the others around me can’t grab it before the owner does