Worth Reading**

The Real Complications of Obesity
from Dances With Fat by danceswithfat

Tragedy struck when Yolanda Reese-Brooks passed away.  Tragedy struck again when the story hit the press.  Officials claimed that she died of complications of obesity and health professionals at the scene estimated her weight at 500 pounds, and removed a sliding glass door to get her out of the house to the hospital.  I know that because every story mentioned those details before they mentioned her name.

Things that many of the stories forgot to mention or buried:  Her actual weight was 360 pounds.  She was bedridden because of a crushed pelvis and ruptured bladder from a traffic accident in 2011. Her name was Yolanda Reese-Brooks, she was a wife, mother, sister and daughter

There are complications from obesity involved here but it’s not about Yolanda Reese-Brooks’ weight. The complications are about how quickly medical professionals will blame body size for everything, how police and fire officials overestimated her weight by  140 pounds – almost 40%.  My girlfriend and others I know weigh more than 360 pounds and fit through a regular door so why did they need to remove a sliding door to get her out and how was it newsworthy if they did? How completely insensitive the news has been in reporting the end of a life.

A journalist with courage would report this at the tragedy it is and start asking questions –  Why didn’t this woman didn’t get the healthcare she needed? Could she not afford it?  Did a very justified fear of being mistreated by a healthcare provider keep her from getting healthcare?  Did the constant shame, stigma and bullying that is heaped on fat people in our society make her think that her body wasn’t worthy of care?  Did rampant ableism make her ashamed to get the mobility aids that she needed?  Was mental illness involved? Are the other reports about this de-humanizing it because that’s what people need to feel ok about flocking to stories about fat people dying to see if they had to cut out a wall or use a special ambulance? If a 400 pound man can run a marathon,  why are we so quick to assume that a 360 pound woman died from being fat?

Some people seem to forget that fat people are indeed human.  We deserve human respect.  When we die we deserve more than a headline that says “Obese, bed-ridden Warren woman’s death was accidental.” (I’m looking at you Detroit Free Press)

The fact that the news of someone’s death could be treated so poorly is the product of the confluence of a number of problems we have in our society – the conflation of weight and health; the acceptable and even encouraged stigmatizing, shaming, and bullying of fat people; the stubborn refusal of the medical establishment to treat fat people’s health issues using evidence-based medicine rather than treating their body size; rampant healthism and ableism; the media’s willingness to use fat people as objects to sensationalize; the government’s comfort waging a war against citizens (including children) for how they look, and encouraging others to do the same; and the ways that this constant treatment leads some fat people to believe that they deserve this treatment until and unless their body is a different size.

Society tries to demand that we solve social stigma through weight loss and says until we do that we deserve to be treated incredibly poorly by every facet of society.  We can reject that and  demand that society solves social stigma by ending social stigma. Yolanda Reese Brooks deserved better and so does every other fat person – we have every right to demand it and to fight for it.

 

{Bolding is by me not original author}

Life begins at the end of your comfort zone.

– Neale Donald Walsch

 

Anything that’s human is mentionable, and anything that is mentionable can be more manageable. When we can talk about our feelings, they become less overwhelming, less upsetting, and less scary. The people we trust with that important talk can help us know that we are not alone. ~Fred Rogers (Mr. Roger

 

 

 

 

 

 

Log in to write a note

Great entry..and you are right, the heavy set are people too. It is sad how the news media have to twist the truth because they want a “good story”. It is sad that we will never know the real reason behind this womans death…it is all about the “story”. How sad for this womans family.

Thank you. You are absolutely right: it is worth reading. I nominated it to PC!

Absolutely!

November 6, 2012

i can so relate. take care,

November 6, 2012

So sad that her size was what was focused on instead of the circumstances behind it. Back in the days of Henry the 8th, being a heavier person meant you had food to eat and the heavier you were, the wealthier you were because it meant you had enough food.

November 6, 2012

Well said.

November 6, 2012

That is very very true. I’ve seen it all my life. Now its the Multiple Sclerosis and my weight. I’m not even over 300 lbs, haven’t been in years, but it doesn’t matter. To people, you are fat, and you’ll die from it. Also rarely do people take into consideration why you are like this? Genetics? Illness? Medication? Each time I have to take Steroids for a MS flare-up I gain anywhere from 10-15 lbs, that don’t come of by themselves when I’m done with the steroids, I have to work on them as if I ate them on…. I’m glad you posted this article. Thank you!

November 6, 2012

Patients are also being refused hip surgery if they are morbidly obese (medical term based on BMI, not a judgment call). I would venture to guess that the reason for the sliding door bit was because they could not use a regular stretcher and a larger one was too wide for a regular door.

November 6, 2012

I think it’s absolutely appalling how it is deemed perfectly OKAY to talk badly about overweight people and insult them and depict them in insulting ways in this country, even when it’s no longer widely considered ok to treat any other group of people that way. Every morning we watch the tv news as we have our breakfast and coffee, before going to work. And seems like every morning, just as we are starting to eat our breakfast, there’s some story about how unhealthy overweight people are. Joe’s overweight, but he is strong and healthy, and I don’t think it’s right that he and many others have to have this thrown at them every time they watch the news. hugs, Nicky

November 6, 2012

Great article… when I was younger I had a HORROR of this kind of story – it made me think that it was inevitable that one day I’d end up being that poor lady in the bed if I couldn’t pull off a miracle and get myself down to a socially acceptable size. Then I grew up and realised that it wasn’t going to happen either way. I’m fat, so what? I’m not crippled by it.

November 6, 2012

My health problems have very little or nothing to do with my body weight/size. I could have been 100lbs and still messed up my back and my knee. And right now I’m using a cane and not caring what anyone else might think about it. If they’re so shallow that they think ‘oh, there’s a fat woman, ugh!’ screw them!(huggles)

November 6, 2012

This is the second time today that I have heard a story of someone who has passed and can’t defend themselves, being maligned. So sad!